We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Privacy Notice
Accept
BASIC thinking InternationalBASIC thinking International
  • SOCIAL MEDIA
  • MARKETING
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • BUSINESS
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • GREEN
Reading: Verdict: Users have no right to pixelation on Google Earth
Share
BASIC thinking InternationalBASIC thinking International
Search
  • SOCIAL MEDIA
  • MARKETING
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • BUSINESS
  • TECHNOLOGY
  • GREEN
Follow US
© 2003 - 2023 BASIC thinking GmbH
erde-foto-unsplash-com-nasa
Technology

Verdict: Users have no right to pixelation on Google Earth

Christian Erxleben
Last updated: June 25, 2020
Christian Erxleben Published June 25, 2020
Unsplash.com / NASA
SHARE

Google Earth is a wonderful tool to discover the world. Thereby we make partly curious discoveries. Now a homeowner wanted the service to pixelate his property. The district court of Itzehoe made its decision – and did not grant the complaint.

We all have a right to protect our privacy. This applies even to public figures – like the german Chancellor Angela Merkel.

That’s why no one is allowed to take photographs with a telephoto lens in the garden or living room of private individuals and make the pictures publicly or privately accessible. All this is enshrined in the second article of the German Constitution in the general right of personality.

When two fundamental rights clash

However, it is often the case that in the event of a dispute, two different legal regulations come into conflict. On the one hand, there is the right of personality, for example, and on the other hand the right to freedom of information from the fifth article of the Basic Law.

For the judging judges the question then arises: Which right is more worthy of protection? Which right is more valuable in an individual case? This was exactly the problem facing the Itzehoe Regional Court (LG).

Specifically, a homeowner had sued Google for pixelating his house. The judges did not comply with this request in their ruling.

There is no fundamental right to pixelation on Google Earth

In their statement of reasons, they argue that neither persons nor other details from the private life of the applicant and his family can be seen on the relevant photograph.

In addition, the marker lands between four plots of land when the address is entered in Google Maps. A detailed allocation or even spying out is therefore not possible.

According to the judges, the pixelation desired by the house owner also leads to Google Earth being “rendered unusable”. The public interest in obtaining information should be taken into account in this case.

Although the judgement is not yet final, it seems clear: There is no fundamental right to pixelation. If personal details can be seen on the corresponding recording on Google Earth, however, the situation is probably different.

TAGGED: Google
Christian Erxleben June 25, 2020
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Email
By Christian Erxleben
Follow:
Christian Erxleben is a journalist from Nuremberg, Germany. He is also the editor in chief of the famous German online magazine BASIC thinking. His interests include social media, marketing and tech. Follow him on Twitter.
Previous Article hand-haelt-smartphone-mit-apps-e1557456452439 Because of Corona: Google Maps introduces new security features
Next Article nacht-sternenhimmel The most frequently asked questions about space – and their answers

Stay Connected

5.1k Like
180 Follow
1.9k Follow
260k Subscribe

Latest News

facebook-multiple-profiles
Facebook: Create multiple personal profiles – here’s how
September 22, 2023
apple-ios-17-iphone-15-pro-3-up
iOS 17: What’s in the new iPhone update
September 19, 2023
google-emoji-kitchen
Emoji Kitchen: Create your own emojis in Google Search
September 15, 2023
WhatsApp: How to transfer data from an iPhone to Android
September 14, 2023
Clubhouse
The new Clubhouse: What can the new Clubhouse app do?
September 12, 2023
whatsapp-mac
This is the new WhatsApp app for the Mac – with group calling
September 4, 2023

You Might also Like

apple-ios-17-iphone-15-pro-3-up
Technology

iOS 17: What’s in the new iPhone update

Beatrice Bode Beatrice Bode September 19, 2023
google-emoji-kitchen
Technology

Emoji Kitchen: Create your own emojis in Google Search

Maria Gramsch Maria Gramsch September 15, 2023
chatgpt-inhalt-videos-zusammenfassen
Technology

ChatGPT plugin: This is how you can have videos summarised for you

Fabian Peters Fabian Peters August 28, 2023
Show More

About us

BASIC thinking is a modern media company that reaches over 25 million page impressions worldwide.

Categories

Ad Business Entertainment Green Marketing Social Media Technology

Quick Links

  • About us
  • Advertising
  • BASIC thinking Germany
  • Imprint
  • Privacy Policy
BASIC thinking InternationalBASIC thinking International
Follow US

© 2003 - 2023 BASIC thinking GmbH

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?